Is There a Duty To Obey The Law?

Is There a Duty to Obey the Law, by Christopher Wellman and A. trick Simmons is a for-and-against style examination and attempt to answer this years old question. Christopher Wellman, a self-avowed statist argues that we do have a virtuous responsibility to obey just laws of a legitimate regime. While, Christopher A. lav Simmons argues that we do not have a moral duty to obey even just laws of a legitimate regime. In general the authors of both sections tend to devout most of their conviction not defended their acresd belief, but either defending the philosophic school of thought that aligns with said position or by attempting to refute other contradictory philosophies. Wellman devotes the bulk of his try exploitation and justifying Samaritanism as the means to require the moral duty. Simmons spends the vast legal age of his effort attempting to refute why certain schools of thought much(prenominal) as Associative, Transactional, and Natural State Theories are inadequate in justifying the core justification for a moral duty of obedience. I will briefly summarize and critique each authors key concepts and conclude with my own beliefs on this matter. unnecessary to say, even upon completion of this work their remains much ambiguity and questions regarding an individuals moral duty to obey the law.




Wellman begins his essay is a way that made it hard for me to take the loosening of his work seriously. He volunteers a narrative of viewing a bumper sticker as a child. The sticker read, Taxation is slavery. His response, enter in the first few pages of his essay was one of horror, and that he recalls looking forward to the day when he could pay taxes as he was in awe of all good things political relation had done. ( 3) Being that Wellman had such a deep and lifelong tell apart affair with the state it seems difficult to see his work as being in any way impartial, or philosophical, quite as a compilation of what he viewed as the shell arguments to defend the state he adores.
Wellmans defense of the state (ours or any...If you want to get a full essay, exhibition it on our website: Orderessay



If you want to get a full essay, wisit our page: write my essay .